A national legal service is vital to tackling unmet need and improving access to justice
Professor Liz Curran, Professor of Justice Reform and Legal Innovation at Nottingham Law School, explains why the Justice Committee’s recommendations in its second Report offer the Government an opportunity to address unmet legal need through earlier intervention, independent legal support and a more coherent approach to access to justice
The House of Commons Justice Committee’s second report on Access to Justice: Access to Legal Services, published on 19 November, provides an important opportunity for the Government to address the growing problem of unmet legal need in England and Wales.
My evidence and testimony are cited 14 times in the report, with several of my recommendations reflected in the Committee’s conclusions.
I strongly welcome the Justice Committee’s proposals. In particular, its recommendation for a national legal service reflects the evidence-based case I have made for a more accessible and coordinated system of legal support.
However, such a service must have statutory independence and a clear focus on improving access to justice. Experience from other jurisdictions demonstrates the importance of establishing services with the independence and remit needed to meet this purpose.
Early legal help can prevent problems escalating
There is a significant need for reform. Many people struggle to recognise when they have a legal problem, understand their rights or identify where to find reliable advice. By the time they access support, their circumstances may have deteriorated, creating substantial personal, social and economic costs.
My research highlights the importance of early intervention, trusted relationships and accessible routes into legal assistance.
Whether the issue is housing, debt, employment, family breakdown or welfare benefits, timely legal help can prevent problems from spiralling into crises.
Early support improves outcomes for individuals while reducing avoidable pressure on courts and public services. The Committee has drawn on this evidence in developing a number of its recommendations.
The Committee’s proposal for a national legal service, incorporating a single, trusted point of access similar to NHS 111, is particularly important.
It reflects what the evidence tells us people need: clear information, effective assessment of their circumstances and straightforward routes to specialist support when required.
Access to justice must also be recognised as a cross-government responsibility. It requires coordinated investment and long-term planning, rather than a fragmented system of short-term initiatives.
Reform must include sustainable funding and stronger regulation
I also welcome the Committee’s consideration of alternative funding for access to justice in civil law.
The report draws on research by me and Professors Ching and Jarman - Regulatory Access to Justice - alongside other evidence, in considering how alternative funding streams could be developed and ringfenced to support access to legal services.
This is particularly important given the constraints on public finances and the scale of unmet legal need. Preventative investment in legal support can deliver significant longer-term value.
When people receive help at the earliest stage, problems are more likely to be resolved quickly. Avoidable costs are reduced, and individuals are better able to participate in work, education and community life.
Access to justice should not depend on where someone lives or their ability to navigate a fragmented system.
The Committee also endorsed concerns I raised about the effectiveness of the existing regulatory framework. My research and oral evidence highlighted weaknesses in a system that appears unable to fulfil its statutory objective of improving access to justice.
Addressing these weaknesses will be essential if regulatory reform is to make a meaningful difference to the availability and accessibility of legal services.
Government must act on the recommendations
The report represents an important opportunity to move beyond incremental changes and address the underlying problems in the legal support system.
These proposals offer a way to build a more coherent, accessible and evidence-based approach to legal support. If implemented effectively, they could help ensure that legal rights are practical and meaningful for everyone, not just those with the resources and knowledge to access assistance independently.
The Government needs to respond much more positively to this second report following its tepid and highly unsatisfactory response to the Justice Committee’s first report. Failing to take forward these evidence-based recommendations would reflect poorly on the Government.
As I have consistently argued, tinkering around the edges of a broken system is failing the public. Too many people are being made homeless, exposed to domestic abuse and pushed into poverty while action is delayed.
This report offers the Government a way forward. Earlier, more holistic legal support can prevent problems escalating and becoming entrenched. It can give people the opportunity to resolve difficulties before they reach crisis point and, importantly, offer hope.
The Government must recognise, as the Justice Committee has, that access to justice requires action at the earliest possible stage.