Skip to content

UK competitiveness: how the economic performance of places differs across the country

Economic performance varies considerably between places in the UK. Territorial competitiveness provides one way of measuring these differences and assessing the factors that may shape an area’s future economic performance. Nottingham Business School’s Professor Piers Thompson, author of the Competitiveness Index, explains.

ExplainerBusiness and economy

What you need to know

  • Territorial competitiveness looks at how successfully different places perform economically and how well positioned they are to improve in the future.

  • Economic performance is uneven across the UK, with significant differences between regions and local areas.

  • Competitiveness is consists of more than productivity or economic output, including factors such as skills, infrastructure, investment, innovation and access to opportunities.

  • Understanding these differences can help explain why some places are better able to respond to economic change and build future prosperity.

  • Improving the UK’s economic performance therefore involves considering the strengths and challenges of different places, rather than treating the economy as a single, uniform entity.

What is territorial competitiveness?

Ultimately, for an area to be competitive it must create positive outcomes for the population of the area, so their standards of living improve.

Territorial competitiveness is a measure of the success of an area’s economy.

It captures not only how well it is doing now, but also how well it is expected to do in the future.

It can be measured at different scales; local competitiveness, regional competitiveness or national competitiveness.

This relates to how an area can attract and retain firms and provide them with the correct conditions – such as skills and infrastructure - to capture and sustain high market share, and to generate high levels of value from the goods and services they produce.

Are there winners and losers from local, regional and national competitiveness?

When one area (locality, region or nation) ‘wins’ by improving its competitiveness this doesn’t have to result in another area ‘losing’.

For example, the development of Artificial Intelligence (AI) related companies in California will increase territorial competitiveness through creating well-paid jobs and a high value product that can be sold across the world.

Other areas do not necessarily lose out as AI firms will create a demand for microchips being produced in other regions. This boosts the value of production from these regions and generates employment opportunities for their population.

Industries in other regions may use the AI tools created to lower costs and increase production, so again the areas hosting these industries may also increase their competitiveness.

A negative outcome would be more likely if an area’s success comes through making products produced in another area obsolescent and/or removes the need for particular roles.

If AI were to replace more routine roles in insurance and finance this could reduce the outcomes enjoyed by the populations of areas with high levels of these industries.

Even if no areas experience a drop in standards of living, some areas may benefit more than others, so there may be some relative losers as the population of a region experiences improvements in living standards, but not as quickly as elsewhere.

How do we measure territorial competitiveness?

Territorial competitiveness can be measured in terms of the resources that are available to produce high value outputs or alternatively based on the outcomes achieved. It might also be measured as a combination of these two.

When based on the resources available in the area this is known as input competitiveness. The resources considered might be the presence of skilled labour, existing innovative businesses, and knowledge centres such as universities, but could also include a well-functioning set of laws and regulations.

Outcome or process competitiveness is based on the extent the area’s population enjoys positive outcomes, for example low unemployment and well-paid jobs.

Others suggest that a broader range of outcomes that affect the population’s standard of living should be considered, such as working conditions and the quality of the living environment.

A wide range of indexes have been created to capture competitiveness such as the Global Competitiveness Index (at the national level),  World Competitiveness Index of Regions and Regional Competitiveness Index (at the regional level), and the UK Competitiveness Index (at the local level for the UK).

These are frequently measured to capture the relative competitiveness of areas. Individual areas are compared to the most competitive area or the average competitiveness of areas covered

Which areas of the UK are the most competitive and which are the least?

Competitiveness is not uniform across the UK. The UKCI, for example, finds there to be considerable differences not only between regions, but also within regions.

The most competitive localities in the UK are found in London. The financial centre of the City of London leads the rankings by a considerable margin.

The least competitive local areas, however, are spread more widely across the country.

These are often areas that previously relied on employment from extractive industries such as coal mining, or manufacturing, with examples being Blaenau Gwent in Wales and Redcar and Cleveland in the North East of England.

Can we ‘rewire the state’ or ‘level up’ the economy of the UK?

Both the current and previous governments of the UK have sought to rebalance the UK economy so that success is not concentrated in London and the South East.

This has included investments in projects in towns and cities across the UK, and an increased focus on devolution of power to local decision makers to allow policies and investments to focus more directly on local needs.

There are generally larger differences in competitiveness between local areas within a given region, than between regional averages. This is sometimes overlooked in the policies seeking to produce more even outcomes across the UK.

For example, large investments through the Innovation Accelerator programme were made in Greater Manchester, although Manchester itself is one of the more competitive areas in the North West region.

Devolution will put more of the power to make these decisions in the hands of elected mayors who can be held accountable by the electorate and should have a better appreciation of the subtle differences in competitiveness within the areas they are responsible for.

Local decision makers will still need to make difficult decisions, for example, supporting projects that boost competitiveness in one particular locality, or choosing interventions that benefit more localities within their area.

An example, of this would be whether to seek to attract innovative firms to the East Midlands Freeport or those that would provide employment opportunities for a larger number of residents.

More from NTU Source

See the latest news from NTU