Impact case study
Crime Drop, Security and Victimisation
Unit(s) of assessment: Social Work and Social Policy
Research theme: Safety and Security of Citizens and Society
School: School of Social Sciences
Research on criminology at NTU, led by Professor Andromachi Tseloni, has focused in particular on criminal victimisation inequalities and falling crime rates around the world. The research has:
- changed the way victimisation is conceptualised, measured, and reported in official crime surveys
- transformed the methodological evaluation of the impact of security devices on crime and repeat victimisation.
For example, Professor Andromachi Tseloni has:
- worked with the Home Office, where her research directly informed the methodological training of crime survey analysts
- influenced the crime reduction practices and responses to crime of police forces in England and Wales
- advised social researchers at the Scottish Crime and Justice Survey on questionnaire design, hard to reach populations and the use of sampling
- worked on consultations about official crime data in England and Wales, as Vice-Chair and later Chair of the Crime and Justice Statistics Network
- as a board member on the Nottingham Crime and Drugs Partnership since 2012, Professor Tseloni has advised on crime rates and patterns in Nottinghamshire.
As well as having a significant impact in the United Kingdom, Professor Tseloni's research has achieved an international reach by influencing the work of crime reduction agencies in Australia, Israel, New Zealand, the Netherlands, the USA and Greece.
Criminal victimisation inequalities
Prior to Professor Tseloni's research, victimisation risk factors were usually based on the dichotomy between victims and non-victims. This approach overlooks repeat victimisation, which accounts for a large proportion of crime. It also over-estimates victimisation risk and underestimates repeat victimisation, even though crime is best prevented when focussing on repeat victims.
Professor Tseloni's victimisation research informs theory and crime prevention by examining the entire distribution of crime incidents (rather than the dichotomy of victim / non-victim) over both contextual and individual risk factors.
International crime drop and security
Crime rates have fallen significantly in recent times across the world, but until Professor Tseloni's collaborative work, research focussed on the US and Canada and explained the reduction in terms of the potential effect of criminal justice policies.
Tseloni's collaborative work showed that the reductions in crime rates were international in nature. This research then tested international rather than criminal justice explanations, in particular the hypothesis that generalised and improved security was the main driver of crime falls. The analysis confirmed that the security hypothesis holds with regards to the vehicle crime drops cross-nationally and to some extent for the fall in burglary across England and Wales.
Research with police forces
Tseloni's research has had an impact on internal practices in police forces. In 1997, her work with the Humberside police force helped them to identify that the relatively higher crime rate in their area was partly due to the quality of their crime recording systems. A project with the Metropolitan Police Force in 2006 gave them a better understanding of the statistics around their policing of ethnic minority communities.
These official reports draw on Professor Tseloni’s research:
- Order in the courts: Restoring trust through local justice. London: Centre for Social Justice, 2009. (Corroborates impact in relation to area distribution of crime rates and repeat victimisation).
- Understanding victimisation and risk: Findings from the New Zealand crime and safety survey 2006 in an international context. Wellington: New Zealand Ministry of Justice, 2009. (Corroborates impact in relation to distribution of repeat victimisation between different socio-economic groups).
- 2008-2009 Scottish crime survey: Technical report. (Corroborates impact in relation to impact on design of questions and levels of analysis within Scottish Crime Survey).
- Overcoming barriers to trust in crime statistics: England and Wales. London: UK Statistics Authority, 2010. (Corroborates impact in relation to impact on design of questions and levels of analysis within British Crime Survey).
- Community safety barometer. Provincial Government of the Western Cape, 2011. (Corroborates impact in relation to the measurement of perception of risk and repeat victimisation between different socio-economic groups).
- Preventing repeat victimization: A systematic review. Stockholm: BRA, the Swedish National Council for Crime Prevention, 2012. (Corroborates impact in relation to distribution of repeat victimisation between different socio-economic groups).
- Focus on violent crime and sexual offences, 2011-12. London: Office for National Statistics, 2013. (Corroborates impact in relation to confidence surrounding international crime drop).
- Tseloni, A., 2006. 'Multilevel modelling of the number of property crimes: Household and area effects'. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A-Statistics in Society, 169, Part 2. 205-33.
- Tseloni, A. and Zarafonitou, C., 2008. 'Fear of crime and victimisation: A multivariate multilevel analysis of competing measurements'. European Journal of Criminology, 5(4). 387-409.
- Tseloni, A., Ntzoufras, I., Nicolaou, A. and Pease, K., 2010. 'Concentration of personal and household crimes in England and Wales’. European Journal of Applied Mathematics, Special Issue on Mathematical Models for Criminality, 21. 325-48.
- Tseloni, A., Mailley, J., Farrell, G. and Tilley, N., 2010. 'Exploring the international decline in crime rates'. European Journal of Criminology, 7(5). 375-94.
- Farrell, G., Tseloni, A., Tilley, N. and Mailley, J., 2011. 'The crime drop and the security hypothesis'. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 48(2). 147-75.
- Tilley, N., Tseloni, A. and Farrell, G., 2011. 'Income disparities of burglary risk. Security availability during the crime drop'. British Journal of Criminology, 51(2). 296-313.
- Van Dijk, J. Tseloni, A. and Farrell, G., 2012. The international crime drop: New directions in research. Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.
- Research and Statistics Directorate, Home Office, UK on postcode sector predictions of crime rates, fear and disorder based on the 2000 British Crime Survey and Census area characteristics and hierarchical modelling of crime rates drawn from the 2000 British Crime Survey.
- University of Macedonia, Greece, Research Committee, Small Grants Programme to explore bivariate zero-inflated Poisson modelling of personal and property crimes in England and Wales.
- ESRC Research Grant (RES-000-22-2386) Sustaining the Crime Drop in Industrialised Nations: A Crime-Specific Problem-Solving Approach.