Impact case study
Transforming Thoracic Trauma Surgery Education and Training by Design
Unit(s) of assessment: Art and Design: History, Practice and Theory
Research theme: Medical Technologies and Advanced Materials
School: School of Art & Design; School of Architecture, Design and the Built Environment
Senior Research Fellow Richard Arm’s work has had a significant impact by improving thoracic surgical education and training for military and clinical practitioners working in extreme emergency environments, leading to improved clinical confidence and competence. Limited availability of cadavers, and manikins that lack a lifelike ‘feel’, had constrained training for thoracic trauma surgery and therefore surgeons’ capacity to save lives.
With industrial, clinical and military partners, NTU’s Flexural Composites Laboratory used composite elastomers and additive manufacturing to create life-like thoracic manikins that make realistic training possible. By enhancing the experiential learning of lifesaving procedures for surgeons and emergency responders they have benefitted personnel in NHS trauma units and regional training hubs, the Air Ambulance Service, the Army, Navy, RAF, British special forces and NATO partners/allies. The manikins are sold commercially as PROSimbodie©, creating new employment and increased revenues for manufacturer Trauma FX (TFX).
As a Senior Research Fellow, Arm has led research since 2012 in the School of Art and Design’s, Flexural Composites Research Laboratory, within the Advanced Textiles Research Group. The group’s focus on materials means it draws upon a number of research approaches, including the craft knowledge Arm has developed working with composite elastomers and additive manufacture. In this, the group’s work shares many of the characteristics of practice-based art and design research, combining embodied process with deep collaboration beyond the field. Close engagement with medical experts at the Queen’s Medical Centre (QMC), Nottingham and Ministry of Defence (MOD), and expert users such as the East Midlands Air Ambulance Service has made it possible for Arm to produce ‘biofidelic’ simulations of human organs, characterise them systematically and prove them in clinical training settings.
The underpinning research grew out of two grants awarded in 2012, which demonstrated and tested the potential to work with silicone polymers to create realistic simulations of the tissues of the human head and thorax – faithful to the variety of textures and structures that occur in nature. Working with surgeons at the QMC, the research was developed through the deep study of the anatomy of the thorax, including organs, tissues, and membranes. Arm used medical imaging data to build high-precision computer models and produce 3D printed moulds which he used in a sophisticated casting process to make simulations that are both anatomically correct and life-like in how they feel. It is this sequence that makes the work particularly innovative, drawing together Arm’s embodied craft knowledge and the anatomical expertise of medical collaborators, to produce hyper-realistic sensual effects through a composite polymer moulding technique.
Proof of concept research was extended through two grants. These increased the number of thoracic organs that could be realistically simulated using silicone-based materials to include rib cage, sternum, spine, skin, subcutaneous soft tissue, functioning airways, lung and heart pleura. The work was further developed to make a beating heart and arterial system with internal blood pressure that responds realistically to surgical incisions. Funded research between 2015 and 2017, developed the material specification and production process for a whole thorax simulation which could faithfully mimic the tactile, mechanical and visual properties of human organs and tissues in situ.
Three thoracic trauma trainer prototypes were tested by medical professionals in a trauma management/surgical setting at the Army Medical Simulation Centre and Royal Centre for Defence Medicine. Tests included battle-field thoracotomy surgery as well as a variety of MOD standard operating procedures. Collaborating surgeons at the QMC and the MOD assessed the effectiveness of two prototypes. Their feedback was used to further enhance the realism of the organs and specifically the properties of the pericardium to better replicate the feel of the sac and its response to being cut by surgeons.
Later grants enabled a refinement to the realism of the skin’s structure and behaviour, through enhancements to simulations of the subcutaneous tissues of the face and head in the context of the impact of ballistic projectiles.
Patients requiring a thoracotomy (opening of the chest in an emergency) typically have a low survival rate (2% - 20%) and resuscitative thoracotomy is considered an intervention of last resort to save someone’s life. Hitherto, there were no effective, practical training tools that could prepare surgeons for this procedure through realistic experiential learning before they carry it out on live patients on the battlefield, at the roadside or in operating theatres. In partnership with British company Trauma FX (TFX), Arm’s research produced PROSimbodie©, the only reusable surgical manikin capable of providing emergency services/surgeons with a means to train for life-saving thoracotomy procedures. The production of the whole thorax prototype led TFX, the research output license owner, to release the PROSimbodie© manikin onto the market in February 2019.
The PROSimbodie© manikin is highly valued by medical professionals because of its bio-fidelity, achieved through the materials-based research outlined above. The much-enhanced realism of the whole-team training it makes possible, led to it winning the Royal College of Surgeons ‘Transforming Surgical Education Award’ in 2017. The PROSimbodie© manikin also overcomes barriers to surgical training in Islamic countries, where burial practices limit the availability of cadavers.
Improving UK and NATO field-based Military Surgery
The research has had direct impact on military surgeon training, through the development of prototypes which remain in use by defence medical simulation centres in the UK, including Army Medical Services Training Centre (AMSTC) in York and at the Royal Centre for Defence Medicine (RCDM), including the Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Birmingham. The prototypes have been used by British and German special forces during emergency aircraft evacuation training, to simulate emergency thoracotomy procedures for seriously injured military personnel on board helicopters.
In 2019, two PROSimbodie© manikins, along with the necessary trained operators, were embedded into TFX’s AMSTC support contract. The prototypes are now routinely used by the British military, including when deploying their two field-hospitals. United Kingdom Special Forces medical training events in 2019, were attended by NATO partners and non-NATO allies and led to orders for PROSimbodie© manikins by the German, UAE and Israeli military, delivered by June 2020. In 2019, PROSimbodie© manikins were used in Germany and benefited US, German, Dutch, British and Lithuanian military medics during NATO multinational field-hospital training.
AMSTC confirms that PROSimbodie© has made the simulated learning experience more immersive and improved the MOD’s ability to test surgeons in critical areas and against its standard operating procedures. In particular, AMSTC highlights how PROSimbodie© manikins enhance the assessment of surgeons’ and team members’ roles, and their behaviour, communication and coordination of critical surgical tasks. The bio-fidelity of the body, the simulated organs and their arrangement in the manikin, have enabled ‘surgical teams and emergency responders to enhance the realism of exercises by practicing procedures that otherwise wouldn’t be possible’.
Examples include the chest drain procedure, which requires an incision into the rib cage to admit a tube to drain blood/air out of the chest cavity, and the emergency clamshell thoracotomy, which involves opening the rib cage to access organs. Clinicians trained by AMSTC say that the thoracic anatomy in the PROSimbodie© ‘gives an increased sense of realism’ that means ‘they can practice the whole procedure from start to finish in an environment reflective of actual working conditions’. During conflict, thoracic procedures are regularly carried out, but when forces are not deployed, it is important that clinical personnel practise their skills to maintain a high level of capability. AMSTC confirms the popularity of the mannikins: ‘Whenever we run simulations, clinicians ask if the PROSimbodie© are going to be used.’
Improving pre-hospital Trauma Surgery
The PROSimbodie© manikin has improved medic and paramedic training, enhancing technical skills for pre-hospital procedures by enabling emergency procedures like the clamshell thoracotomy to be practiced in life-like situations. The high-fidelity models were tested at the Royal College of Surgeons, London and by the East Midlands Air Ambulance Service in Nottingham. Consequently, the thoracic simulations are now regularly used for trauma training by first responders in the East Midlands Immediate Care Service, a multi-disciplinary team of doctors that covers the whole of the East Midlands and responds to an average of four life-threatening emergencies a day. The model improved the team’s technical skills, their coordination of operational procedures and their emotional management in response to radical, traumatic and rarely seen procedures. A GP involved states ‘There are many ambulance crews who’ve never actually seen this procedure’.
The PROSimbodie© manikin is used by British emergency services to enhance simulated training/learning and improve pre-hospital trauma care. TFX used PROSimbodie© to support Pre-Hospital Emergency Extracorporeal Life Support training for medical/clinical staff at St Bartholomew’s Hospital. An example of this is Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation simulation which teaches emergency services staff to treat people with severe respiratory failure. Wider applications being explored include out-of-hospital trauma procedures such as emergency amputation and caesarean sections [S4]. Three UK Air Ambulance Services had purchased PROSimbodie© manikins by early 2020.
Improving hospital-based Trauma Training and General Surgery
The PROSimbodie© manikin was tested to improve in-hospital trauma surgery and general surgery training at Queen’s Medical Centre Major Trauma Unit, Nottingham, and the Aintree Hospital Simulation Centre, Liverpool. PROSimbodie© manikins overcome the limitations of using cadavers and animals (in terms of ethics, expense and accuracy) and they provide a cost-effective, reusable and more realistic model that, according to the director of the East Midlands Major Trauma Centre, has ‘resulted in a change to the accuracy of our high-level training’.
One QMC consultant described the training opportunities afforded by the PROSimbodie© as ‘critical’, enabling staff to ‘practice in a no risk environment rather than being trained in a high-risk environment i.e. live surgery’. The PROSimbodie© manikin has enhanced simulated training in emergency care. In January 2020, TFX delivered training with PROSimbodie© to Watford Emergency Department (West Hertfordshire NHS Trust). This involved nurses, consultants and other staff members taking their Certificate of Eligibility for Specialist Registration. University Hospital of Wales, Cardiff purchased a PROSimbodie© manikin in 2019, to teach medical trainees/staff at Cardiff University School of Medicine and Wales Air Ambulance Service.
Commercial impact via the commercialisation of the PROSimbodie© manikin
The production of whole thorax prototypes led the industrial collaborator and research output license owner TFX to commercialise a new product, the PROSimbodie© manikin, for emergency surgical training, which came onto the market in February 2019. This directly led TFX to create a new department at their manufacturing facility in Yorkshire, with one new senior, highly skilled position and three graduate roles. The facility expanded from 2,500 to 7500sq/ft to meet need production demand. The PROSimbodie© manikin delivered £900,000 in turnover to TFX up to July 2020. Sales were further supported when the research work was featured on BBC Radio 4’s Today Programme, broadcast from NTU in February 2020. The TFX licence agreement with NTU committed the company to manufacture and retail 25 units by July 2020, in fact 30 units were achieved. Several accessories and consumable products have also been developed and manufactured through collaboration with TFX to support PROSimbodie© manikin customers. Examples include replaceable skin/fat, pericardium, repair kits and training manuals.
In February 2020, Water Street Healthcare Partners (WSHP), a US-based healthcare strategic investor, merged TFX, Prometheus Medical (PROSimbodie© manikin retailer) and North Carolina’s Combat Medical, (emergency medical solutions provider for military and law enforcement agencies), to form a new company called Safeguard Medical. TFX MD confirmed ‘PROSimbodie©’s one product that’s been instrumental in influencing our merger with Safeguard medical, to access large US medical and military markets.’ The Chief Executive Officer of WSHP stated, ‘This merger is an important first step toward our goal of building a global leader dedicated to developing life-saving products and teaching emergency medical skills for any environment and every skill level’.
- Nandasiri, G.; Ianakiev, A; Dias, T; (2020) Hyperelastic properties of platinum cured silicones and its application in active compression. Polymers, 12, 148. DOI:10.3390/poly120101148
- Mahoney, P., Carr, D., Arm, R., Gibb, I., Hunt, N., Delaney, R. (2017). Ballistic Impacts on an anatomically correct synthetic skull with a surrogate skin/soft tissue layer. International Journal of Legal Medicine. DOI:10.1007/s00414-017-1737-9. Online ISSN 1437-1596.
- Arm, R.; Shahidi, A.; Dias, T., (2019). Mechanical Behaviour of Silicone Membranes Saturated with Short Strand, Loose Polyester Fibres for prosthetic and rehabilitative Surrogate Skin Applications. Materials. 6; 12 (22) DOI:10.3390/ma12223647.
- Arm, R (2015) Royal Centre for Defence Medicine (MoD) Development of a Thoracic Trauma Trainer for the Advancement of Military Operational Surgical Training. Crown Copyright. Report number DMSRSG/2014/09/11 A.
- Arm, R (2017) Centre for Defence Enterprise (MoD) Development of a Thoracic Trauma Trainer for the Advancement of Military Operational Surgical Training. Crown Copyright. Report Number DMSRG/2014/09/11 A.