Skip to content

How Parliament makes laws explained: who writes legislation, how it is scrutinised, and whether Parliament really shapes the final result

One of the most common assumptions about Parliament is that its primary role is to make laws. After all, legislatures are named after their law-making function. But the reality is more complicated. While Parliament is responsible for scrutinising and approving legislation, governments usually control the process and introduce most new laws. This raises an important question: is Parliament really a law-maker, or is its role better understood as influencing and improving laws proposed by others?

ExplainerPolitics and society

What you need to know

  • Most laws begin as government bills.

  • Bills must pass through both the House of Commons and House of Lords before becoming law.

  • Parliament scrutinises legislation through debates and bill committees.

  • The House of Lords plays an important role as a revising chamber.

  • Parliament often influences legislation (through amendments), even when it does not formally defeat the government.

Who writes laws?

Although any MP can theoretically introduce legislation, most new laws are proposed by the government.

Government departments develop policy ideas, draft legislation and decide which proposals should form part of the government's legislative programme. Specialist lawyers known as Parliamentary Counsel then turn policy proposals into legal text.

This means that, in practice, governments dominate the initiation of legislation. Parliament's role begins once a bill is introduced for scrutiny.

How does a bill become law?

A bill normally passes through several stages in both Houses of Parliament.

The first reading is largely a formality. The second reading provides the first major debate, focusing on the principles behind the bill. If agreed, the bill moves to committee stage where it receives detailed line-by-line scrutiny.

Following committee stage, further amendments are considered at report stage before holding a final debate at third reading. The bill then moves to the other House and goes through a similar process before receiving Royal Assent and becoming law.

What role does the House of Lords play?

The House of Lords cannot usually stop legislation permanently, but it can make governments think again.

Unlike the Commons, the government does not normally enjoy a majority in the Lords. Peers are also generally less constrained by party discipline. This allows the Lords to scrutinise legislation in greater detail and propose amendments.

The Lords sees itself as a revising chamber. Its aim is not usually to block legislation but to improve it by identifying flaws, clarifying provisions and suggesting changes.

Does Parliament actually change legislation?

More often than many people realise.

At first glance, the government appears to dominate the legislative process, particularly in the House of Commons where it controls most parliamentary time and usually commands a majority.

However, measuring influence is not simply about government defeats. Research shows that ministers frequently respond to pressure from MPs, peers and parliamentary committees by bringing forward amendments of their own. In many cases, opposition proposals may be rejected initially but later reappear in revised form as government amendments.

Parliamentary influence can therefore be difficult to see because it often happens behind the scenes before a vote is ever held.

Can backbench MPs make laws?

Yes, but it is difficult.

Backbench MPs can introduce Private Members' Bills on issues they care about. Some well-known laws have originated in this way, but the odds of success are relatively low because parliamentary time is limited and government business takes priority.

During the 2019 Parliament, over 1,000 private members' bills were introduced across both Houses, yet fewer than 50 received Royal Assent.

As a result, Private Members' Bills are often as much about raising awareness and encouraging debate as they are about changing the law directly.

Is Parliament a law-maker or a law-influencer?

The answer is both, but it is probably more accurate to describe Parliament as a law-influencer than a law-maker.

While Parliament must approve legislation before it can become law, governments usually decide what legislation is introduced and when. Parliament's greatest impact comes through scrutiny, revision and pressure that improve the quality of legislation.

Looking only at who proposes laws risks overlooking this wider influence. Much of Parliament's contribution lies in asking difficult questions, exposing weaknesses and persuading governments to think again.

Looking beyond the headlines

When a new law is announced, attention usually focuses on the government minister behind it. Yet the final version of a bill is often shaped by MPs, peers, committees, and outside experts throughout the parliamentary process.

Parliament may not be the primary author of most legislation, but it plays a crucial role in improving laws before they reach the statute book. In that sense, its influence extends far beyond the simple question of whether it can defeat the government.

More from NTU Source

See the latest news from NTU